Reviewing beatties Life of Campbell in the Quarferly in 1849, Lockhart expressed the hope that no one would ever tell Campbell's story without making due acknow ledgment to 'the best stay of his declining period.' He would be a bold man who would think of doing so. As well might one expect to write a life of Johnson with out the aid of Boswell as expect to tell Campbell's story without reference to Dr Beattie. In addition to my acknowledgments to him, I have to express my in debtedness to Mr Cyrus Redding's 'reminiscences of Thomas Campbell,' which, though badly put together, yet contain a mass of valuable information about the poet, especially in his more intimate relations. For the rest I have made considerable use of Campbell's corre spondence, and have, I trust, acquainted myself with all the more important references made to him in con temporary records, and in the writings of those who knew him. To several of my personal friends, par ticularly to Mr G. H. Ely, I am obliged for hints and helpful suggestions, which I gratefully acknowledge. J. C. H.
